Mansfield University
All-PSAC Selections
1985-2009
| 2009 | Nicole Yost | 1st Team |
| 2008 | Jessica Christ (2B) | 2nd Team |
| 2007 | Shana Markwis (OF) | 2nd Team |
| Michelle Forsburg (Util) | 2nd Team | |
| 2006 | Jessica Christ (2B) | 1st Team |
| 2005 | Tricia Bailey (3B) | 1st Team |
| Heather Long (OF) | 2nd Team | |
| Nancy Quinn (DP) | 2nd Team | |
| Sytiva Seitz (Util) | 2nd Team | |
| 2004 | Alison Tagliaferri (Util) | 1st Team |
| Jaclyn Laskowski (1B) | 2nd Team | |
| Tricia Bailey (3B) | 2nd Team | |
| Nancy Quinn (DP) | 2nd Team | |
| 2003 | Jaclyn Laskowski (1B) | 1st Team |
| Jes Ricker (3B) | 1st Team | |
| Nancy Quinn (DP) | 2nd Team | |
| Alison Tagliaferri (Util) | 2nd Team | |
| 2002 | Jess Ricker (3B) | 2nd Team |
| Alison Tagliaferri (Util) | 2nd Team | |
| 2001 | Jess Ricker (3B) | 2nd Team |
| 2000 | Jess Ricker (3B) | 1st Team |
| Kelly Morris (Pitcher) | 2nd Team | |
| 1999 | Kim Swarts (OF) | 2nd team |
| 1998 | Rosie Pagana (C) | 2nd Team |
| Kim Swarts (OF) | 2nd Team | |
| Melissa Tyson (Util) | 2nd Team | |
| 1996 | Stephanie Kent (3B) | 2nd Team |
| 1993 | Stacey McMail | |
| 1992 | Corinne Clari | |
| Patti Buffington | ||
| Stacy McMail | ||
| 1988 | Deb Gmys |
*Note: 1995 was the first year the PSAC had 1st and 2nd team honors.