Mansfield University
All-PSAC Selections
1986-2004
| 2004 | Alissa Gallagher | 1st team |
| 2003 | Heather Long | 2nd team |
| 2002 | Gretchen Reschke | 1st team |
| Brooke Fronczkewicz | 2nd team | |
| 2001 | Gretchen Reschke | 1st team |
| Kristi Swartz | 2nd team | |
| 2000 | Jamie Huffcut | 1st team |
| Gretchen Reschke | 1st team | |
| Lisa Bray | 2nd team | |
| 1999 | Jamie Huffcut | 1st team |
| Gretchen Reschke | 1st team | |
| Lisa Bray | 2nd team | |
| 1998 | Misty Drasher | 1st team |
| Jamie Huffcut | 2nd team | |
| 1997 | Shanna Vital | 1st team |
| Misty Drasher | 2nd team | |
| Tandy Carey | 2nd team | |
| Jamie Huffcut | 2nd team | |
| 1995 | Amanda Keylor | 2nd team |