Mansfield University
All-PSAC Selections
1987-2008
| 2008 | Abe Yeakel | 1st team |
| Ryan Giblin | 1st team | |
| Irv Slighter | 1st team | |
| Matt Young | 2nd team | |
| Chris Miller | 2nd team | |
| 2007 | Ryan Wyland | 1st team / 2nd team P /Athlete of the Year |
| Ryan Giblin | 2nd team | |
| Eric Rosenberger | 2nd team | |
| 2006 | Colby Rickabaugh | 1st team |
| Ryan Wyland | 1st team | |
| Ryan Giblin | 2nd team | |
| Scott Erickson | 2nd team | |
| Matt Allegretto | 2nd team | |
| 2005 | D.J. Hoshauer | 1st team |
| Eric Baker | 1st team-Athlete of the Year | |
| Brett Shockloss | 1st team | |
| Colby Rickabaugh | 1st team | |
| Travis Wurster | 2nd team | |
| Adam Lorson | 2nd team | |
| Kane Stein | 2nd team | |
| 2004 | Eric Baker | 1st team |
| Matt Mills | 1st team | |
| Josh Rearick | 1st team | |
| Jeff Papi | 1st team | |
| Marty Rakaczewski | 1st team | |
| D.J. Hoshauer | 2nd team | |
| Brandon Brokaw | 2nd team | |
| 2003 | Brett Brown | 2nd team |
| Dan Yoder | 2nd team-Rookie of the Year | |
| 2002 | Eddie Frame | 1st team |
| Chris Hafich | 1st team | |
| Jason Manwarning | 1st team | |
| Greg Martin | 1st team | |
| Brett Brown | 2nd team | |
| Travis Wurster | 2nd team | |
| 2001 | Matt Edwards | 1st team |
| R.J. Lee | 1st team | |
| Doug Evans | 2nd team | |
| Bill Allen | 2nd team | |
| 2000 | Chris Hafich | 1st team |
| Adam Lewis | 2nd team | |
| Scott Costa | 2nd team | |
| Matt Edwards | 2nd team | |
| 1999 | Kris Kann | 1st team |
| Chris McGee | 1st team | |
| Chad Swogger | 1st team | |
| Rod Lee | 2nd team | |
| 1998 | Adam Lewis | 1st team |
| Scott Wilcox | 1st team | |
| A.J. Hoenstine | 2nd team | |
| Chris McGee | 2nd team | |
| Chris Zallie | 2nd team | |
| 1997 | Greg Robertson | 1st team |
| A.J. Hoenstine | 1st team | |
| Mark Munkkittrick | 1st team | |
| Scott Wilcox | 1st team | |
| Mike Marconi | 2nd team | |
| Joe Skelly | 2nd team | |
| 1996 | Greg Robertson | 1st team |
| Duke Neatrour | 1st team | |
| Scott Wilcox | 1st team | |
| Tim Watkins | 1st team | |
| Chris Zallie | 1st team | |
| Matt Butler | 1st team | |
| Mike Resetar | 2nd team | |
| Joe Skelly | 2nd team | |
| 1995 | Tom McCauley | 1st team |
| Greg Robertson | 1st team | |
| Pete Peters | 1st team | |
| Dave Shepard | 1st team | |
| John Michael Cook | 1st team-Athlete of the Year | |
| Mike Cacciotti | 2nd team | |
| 1994 | Tom McCauley | |
| Duke Neatrour | ||
| Mike Myers | ||
| Pete Peters | ||
| Earl Wallace | ||
| 1993 | Tony Galucy | |
| John Michael Cook | ||
| Mike Myers | ||
| Tim Fausnaught | ||
| Earl Wallace | ||
| Steve Micknich | Pitcher of the Year | |
| 1992 | Tony Galucy | |
| Tim Fenton | ||
| Al Probst | ||
| Tim Fausnaught | ||
| Andy McNab | ||
| Steve Micknich | ||
| Jim Beck | ||
| Mike Felix | Rookie of the Year | |
| 1991 | Tim Fenton | |
| Tim Fausnaught | ||
| Al Probst | ||
| 1990 | Kenny Yeich | |
| Mark Powell | ||
| Jerry Waldron | ||
| 1989 | Shawn May | |
| Jerry Waldron | ||
| 1988 | Steve Murphy | |
| Todd Mostoller | Pitcher of the Year | |
| Sean May | ||
| 1987 | Scott Jeffery | Pitcher of the Year |
| Pete Cook | ||
| Tom Royal |
*Note: 1995 was the first year the PSAC had 1st and 2nd team honors.